Tag: CryptoShariah

Is a Crypto Asset Mal? – Part 5 What Type of Mal Is It?Introducing the Shariah Crypto Classification Framework (SCCF)

Banner reading “Is a Crypto Asset Mal? – Part 5,” “What Type of Mal Is It?,” and “Introducing the Shariah Crypto Classification Framework (SCCF)”

Before asking whether a crypto asset is halal, we need to know what type of mal it is in Shariah, because the type decides which Fiqh rules apply. Market labels such as “utility,” “payment,” or “RWA” describe what a token does, or how a regulator treats it, not what it is in Shariah. The Shariah Crypto Classification Framework (SCCF), published here for the first time, sorts every crypto asset that qualifies as mal, starting with one question: is it money or not? The answer tells you which rules govern the asset; whether a particular asset is halal or haram is a separate question that comes later in the series.

Rate this:

Mufti Taqi Usmani’s Fatwa on Cryptocurrency

Text: CRYPTO Cryptocurrency

This note does not seek to examine the various juristic definitions of māl. Rather, it argues that merely describing cryptocurrencies as digital numbers or ledger entries does not seem sufficient to exclude them from the category of māl. The same description applies to modern banking, electronic money, and numerous forms of intangible financial rights. In fact, what we call fiat currencies—such as the Pakistani Rupee or the US Dollar—have themselves largely become ledger entries. The balances held in bank accounts (including those of Islamic banks) are, in reality, digital records.

Rate this:

Fiqh of Cryptos – Part 1 and Part 2

Islamic jurisprudence and cryptocurrency symbols with digital economy elements

The most common objection to crypto assets in Shar’iah discussions is not about risk. It is not about volatility either. It is more basic than that. The objection says there is no ‘thing’ here to judge in the first place. A crypto asset, based on this view, is not property that happens to be risky. It is not property at all. It does not exist. It is only an imaginary or a fictional number in a database, created by a computation. And numbers in a database are not wealth or assets (mal).
If this premise is correct, every later question is already settled. Is a crypto asset property (mal)? Does it carry financial or economic value (maliyyah) in the Shar’iah sense? Is it a form of wealth Shar’iah recognizes (mutaqawwam)? None of these questions need to be asked if the object itself does not exist. This series of articles explores these questions in depth.

Rate this: